Two Daniels - Rabbi and Organic Farmer - Trade Jobs
A rabbi and a farmer meet in a coffee shop. Both are named Daniel. The rabbi says to the farmer, “What if we traded jobs for a day?” One year later, they traded jobs, and this is what they learned:
Rabbi Daniel: Every day is an adventure for a rabbi! Last week, I ventured out to the ‘hinterland’, north of the city, to an organic farm known as “The Cutting Veg.” Trading jobs with farmer Daniel Hoffman, I was struck by the many parallels between synagogue life and the farming experience. Both professions plant seeds for the next generation. Both rabbi-ing and farming demand careful, dedicated labor and faith in the future. Both processes strengthen community and foster holiness.
I spent the morning crouching down planting onion bulbs. I found myself obsessing about planting the onions just right. How could I make sure that the seeds would grow to their full potential? What would they look and taste like? Could I protect them from danger? I was given reassurances and told not to worry; my novice planting skills appeared to be just fine. I would have to let go of my fears and let Mother Nature take over. Will it be a good harvest? We did the best that we could. Now we have to wait and see. Just like so many aspects of our lives, we are called upon to have faith.
"Rabbi Daniel" (Rabbi Daniel Mikelberg at Temple Sinai Congregation of Toronto) and "Farmer Daniel" (Daniel Hoffmann, organic Farmer with The Cutting Veg Organic Farm) at Cutting Veg. Photo courtesy of Rabbi Mikelberg.
This was messy work, but oh, so meaningful! Days later, I still found remnants of the soil imbedded in my fingernails. I’m usually quite concerned about keeping things clean and tidy, but this did not appear to be an option on the farm. As such, the experience was very real! I was reminded that even though I aspire to understand things with right and wrong, good and bad dichotomies, more often than not, this is not a reality. It’s in those messy gray areas that we generally discover true value.
Farmer Daniel: The mystique of the rabbinate has always intrigued me. So, when Rabbi Mikelberg suggested a job trade, I found myself at the Temple Sinai Congregation of Toronto all cleaned up, yarmulke-affixed and ready to “rabbi it up!” Our day began with a morning Sabbath service in which 200 kids connected through music, rituals and Jewish values. Whether you’re 4 years old, or 400, eating challah and singing Hinei Ma Tov never gets old, as far as I’m concerned. We then met with a representative from Jewish Family & Child to explore how Temple Sinai could take a leadership role in addressing the abuse of women within the Jewish community. Since I also have a background in social work, this meeting had particular interest for me, as I recognize violence against women not as a “women’s issue” but as an issue that needs all of our attention. Next we met with a young man in the process of converting to Judaism and then visited two congregants in the hospital to offer support and loving kindness. This was followed by an evening Sabbath service, which embodied the themes of relaxation, celebration and meaning.
But it was the moments in between these activities that were most special to me. In preparation for the evening sermon, we checked out the Torah portion of the week, which addressed the themes of holiness and also of atoning for one’s impurities. Lively discussion ensued. Is it holiness we should aim for, or wholeness? Are we to try to eliminate our impurities, our flaws, our mistakes, or rather to keep working at being more conscious of them? In our talks, we shared what motivates us to do the work we do. We discussed our relationship with prayer and with our spiritual practices. What a privilege to have access to a rabbi for an entire day!
Rabbi Daniel: Over lunch, each farmer reflected on his or her most loved fruit and vegetable. We were asked to think about the growing process of our favorite foods. Such an important question, and yet one that I rarely consider. Hard to appreciate that food never just magically appears on one’s plate! Too often I forget that fruits and vegetables travel a long way before they end up in the supermarket. We have a Jewish tool to open our eyes to this pathway – blessings! Voicing our blessings enables us to pause and express thanks for our many gifts.
That afternoon on the farm, I also chopped potatoes. I learned that potato bushes grow from segments of potatoes that have an embedded eye. It struck me that we were cutting up perfectly good potatoes in order to put them back in the ground! Was this productive? Yes! In fact, each single potato would go on to produce dozens more. Again, this is reflective of Jewish wisdom: As we build for future generations, we sometimes need to make painful sacrifices.
Farmer Daniel: Toward the end of the day, a congregant approached me: “How’s it been to be a rabbi for a day? It must be quite different from farming.” I thought about it for a moment and said, “Not at all actually.”
The more we farmed and rabbi’ed together, the more the similarities between our working lives became apparent. Rabbi Mikelberg’s work is all about healthy relationships -- with congregants, synagogue staff members, fellow clergy, colleagues in the community. On the farm, we too focus on healthy relationships: with the members of our Community Supported Agriculture (CSA) program, with our staff, interns, volunteers, community partners, and with other farmers. Rabbi Mikelberg spends his day sowing seeds -- seeds that grow community and Jewish engagement. On the farm, we not only sow seeds literally (peas, beets, garlic -- yum!), but we also aim to sow seeds that enhance people’s quality of life and support long-term ecological health.
And to be a rabbi requires a great deal of relinquishing of control. When we went to the hospital, we didn’t know whether we’d be greeted warmly or with hostility (and indeed we got both). And in farming, we can work our butts off, but we have no control over the weather or the outcome of the harvest.
As we discussed how we approach our work, the synchronicities continued to reveal themselves. We each view our work as part of the Jewish value of tikkun olam -- repairing of the world. We aim to be of service to those with whom we interact -- perhaps a member of the congregation in need of support, perhaps a farmers market attendee needing cooking tips.
Rabbi Daniel: Significantly, we worked the soil as part of a farming community. This was holy labor! Together we would make a real impact. We planted over 10,000 onion bulbs that morning. On the drive home, I found myself reflecting on the importance of farmers. Away from the city, they are often way off our radar. We need to remember and appreciate that their love of the earth, their hard work and their wholesome intentions are key to making the world a healthy place. As I resume my more traditional Rabbi tasks, I will now bring renewed emphasis to opening my eyes to the natural wonders of our world.
Farmer Daniel: I found myself realizing during our two days together that tikkun olam is possible everywhere. We encountered many others who also aim to be of service: the farm intern who works as a flight attendant and looks out for her passengers with such care; the members of the synagogue social action committee, who give their time, energy and spirit to build community and promote social justice. If my day of rabbi-ing taught me anything, it’s that it doesn’t matter so much what you do. Whether you’re a rabbi, a farmer, a business executive, or a volunteer -- it’s not so much what you do, but the intention, the kavanah, you bring to it.