Search and the other Reform websites:

Are Reform Jews Jewish?

Are Reform Jews Jewish?

Last week, Member of Knesset David Rotem described the Reform movement as "not Jewish" and "another religion." Rotem is a member of Likud-Beitenu, the lead party in the majority coalition. He also chairs the Constitution, Law, and Justice Committee, one of most important Knesset committees that deals, among other issues, with the status of conversion in Israel. His dismissive attitude toward multiple ways to practice Judaism signals a dangerous reality for religious pluralism in Israel.

After an instantaneous and strong response from leaders of the Reform Movement in Israel and the U.S., Rotem apologized when the Knesset was in session yesterday:

"Members of the Reform Movement, and of course all those who were born to Jewish mothers, are considered fully Jewish in all aspects.  I retract what was said and express my apologies to those who were offended by the remarks."

At that same hearing, another Member of Knesset, Shas MK Uri Maklev, proclaimed,

"The Reform Movement is persecuting the Jewish people and breaking it apart. They are the enemies of the Jewish people and cause assimilation."

These offensive words, which caused necessary concern from the Diaspora community, are part of a larger picture. At the Israel Religious Action Center, we know that Reform Judaism is simply one of the many groups defined as "the other" by certain fundamentalist leaders in Israel.

Just last week, I wrote about a Reform synagogue that was vandalized in Ra'anana. This morning there was another so-called "price tag" attack against Arab residents of Jerusalem. Rotem's words were not a direct catalyst to either of these crimes. However, the divisive rhetoric of figures of authority highlighting the separation between "us" and "them," is growing in Israel, and can escalate quickly.

The sequence of this week's events demonstrates our power when we act together. We can stop violence and violent rhetoric in Israel when we organize and work together.  Join us as we continue to hold public figures accountable when they abuse their position to discriminate against minorities in Israel.

Anat Hoffman is the executive director of the Israel Religious Action Center, the public and legal advocacy arm of the Reform Jewish Movement in Israel. She is also the chairwoman of Women of the Wall, a group of Jewish women and men from around the world who strive to achieve the right of women to wear prayer shawls, pray, and read from the Torah collectively and out loud at the Western Wall in Jerusalem.

Anat Hoffman

Published: 2/10/2014

Categories: Israel, Religious Pluralism in Israel
Submit a blog post

Share your voice: accepts submissions to the blog