Hey, That's Not Our Torah Scroll!

May 21, 2014Jane E. Herman

Recently at the regular Shabbat minyan at Temple Shaaray Tefila in New York City, we worshipers were thrown for a bit of a loop when, at the beginning of the Torah service, the rabbi took a scroll from the ark that was different than the one we use each week.

As it turns out, our congregation was lucky to be hosting – for about 48 hours – the "guest scroll," which is in the midst of making its rounds throughout North America on its way to Israel, where it will be used by Women of the Wall to celebrate Rosh Chodesh Tammuz at the Kotel at the end of June. Women of the Wall is the egalitarian advocacy organization that, for nearly three decades, has been working “to achieve social and legal recognition of…women to wear prayer shawls, pray and read from the Torah collectively and out loud at the Western Wall.”

Generously donated by Congregation Beth Israel in San Diego, the scroll’s journey began there in February. In each community it visits, its presence is providing forums in which to discuss, through the lens of Torah values, the pressing civil issues – gender equality, immigration reform, human rights, and religious freedom – currently unfolding in the State of Israel. Once in Israel, the scroll will be given a permanent home in Sha'ar HaNegev, a Reform community in the Northern Negev desert whose sister-city is San Diego.

Although technically speaking, the scroll doesn't belong to Temple Shaaray Tefila or to any of the other nearly two dozen communities it will visit on its way to M’dinat Yisrael, it does, in fact, belong to all of us whose story is detailed in the carefully lettered words on its parchment. Indeed, Torateinu ARZA belongs to all of us, just as does the Western Wall – into whose dry cracks and crevices we have been tucking our memories, stories, and prayers, rolled thin like chiffonade, for much (but not all) of the last few millennia.

As they gather to welcome Rosh Chodesh Tammuz by singing, celebrating, and retelling a piece of our people's story, may the women (and men) of Women of the Wall find that this scroll – our scroll – brings new meaning, energy, and the spirit of each of us (and our individual and collective stories) to their celebrations and their sacred work. So too may this scroll bring our people’s ancient story to the progressive Jewish community of Sha’ar HaNegev, where it can enrich and strengthen the inclusive, egalitarian community our brothers and sisters are building and nurturing for themselves and the generations to come.

Related Posts

The Ethical Conundrum of a Jewish and Democratic State

June 8, 2021
When the State of Israel was established in 1948, its secular founders envisioned a nation that would be both Jewish and attuned to the values of liberal democracy. They were confident that a country with an overwhelming Jewish majority could maintain a Jewish character and ensure civic equality for all its inhabitants.