9 Rosh HaShanah Foods to Prepare in Advance for a Stress-Free Holiday

Tina Wasserman

Even if you're just cooking for your immediate family, making a successful holiday dinner can be an overwhelming, frantic experience. But with some planning, it doesn’t have to be! Here are nine tips for a stress-free preparation of some of Rosh HaShanah’s most iconic dishes.

1. Brisket

You probably know that brisket tastes best if you cook it the day before – but did you know that it can still taste great prepared weeks in advance? Just make sure that once you’ve prepared the brisket, you separate the meat from the gravy. Leave the meat whole and place it in a freezer bag or plastic wrap.

Tina’s Tidbit: When using a freezer bag, place a straw in a partially closed bag and suck out all the air through the straw until you see the bag collapse around the contents of the bag. While still sucking, pull the straw out and completely seal the bag. This will help to protect the flavor and consistency of all your frozen foods.

When it’s almost time to eat, defrost, slice, and combine with the gravy before reheating in a microwave. Whatever you do, don’t reheat your brisket in the oven! The oven will make it dry and overcooked.

2. Chicken Soup

Strained of all meat and vegetables, chicken soup can be refrigerated for up to one week.

Tina’s Tidbit: Freeze the meat without skin and bone, and use it to make the best, most flavorful chicken salad you’ve ever had.

3. Gefilte Fish

Whether you make it as a loaf or rolled into balls, gefilte fish freezes beautifully. Freeze the loaf right in the pan. Freeze shaped balls on a cookie sheet. Once they're frozen, remove and place in a freezer zip-lock bag, then return to freezer. Shortly before you’re ready to eat, defrost it in the refrigerator.

4. Teiglach

Teiglach is that beautiful tower of crisp dough balls cooked in honeyed syrup that can be tough to get just right. For many of us, when we attempt to make this dish we end up with undercooked dough or overcooked, hard syrup. Here’s a foolproof solution: bake the teiglach balls in advance and freeze them. When you’re ready to assemble, which can be two to three days before you’re ready to eat, defrost the balls, make the syrup, and assemble.

5. Kreplach

Kreplach is more than just a Jewish dumpling. It’s traditional Rosh HaShanah food because it’s sealed, signifying our hopes for being sealed in the Book of Life. Once you’ve prepared your kreplach, freeze it on a parchment-lined cookie sheet, then remove the frozen kreplach and place in a freezer bag. No need to defrost: simply place the kreplach directly into soup and heat until the soup is hot and the kreplach are warm.

6. Asparagus

Asparagus season is almost over, so Rosh HaShanah is a great opportunity to get your fix in until next summer. Blanche your asparagus in boiling salted water for two to three minutes until bright green, remove from hot water and place in a bowl of ice water to set the color. Once finished, drain and wrap in paper towel. Refrigerate for up to five days. To eat, either serve cold or reheat in the microwave.

7. Vegetables

Planning on grilling or oven roasting additional vegetables for your Rosh HaShanah dinner? Make them three to four days in advance and refrigerate them. Serve at room temperature, or heat them up in the microwave before serving.

8. Potato Kugel

If your kugel has enough eggs to bind the ingredients, once completely cooked you can freeze in an airtight container. Defrost slowly in the refrigerator and reheat in a 325F oven. If you like your kugels edible, be sure not to reheat it in a microwave!

9. Swiss Chard, Potato and Cheese Gratin

Sephardic Jews traditionally serve this delicious gratin (quajado di pasi kon patata i keso) on Rosh HaShanah. Served piping hot, it makes a wholesome light meal.