Book Review: Exile Music

Review By: 
Marcia R. Rudin

Bolivia admitted approximately 10,000 Holocaust era Jewish refugees, many of them artists and musicians who settled in of La Paz, the capital city situated 12,000 feet above sea level in the Andes Mountains. Jennifer Steil discovered their largely untold story in 2012, when her husband, a U.S. diplomat was posted there.

In researching the subject of her novel, Exile Music (Viking), Steil drew on interviews with survivors and their descendants. The story is narrated by Orly Zingel, who, at age 11, journeys with her parents from Vienna to Genoa to Chile and finally to La Paz, leaving behind her older brother, Willi.

Exhausted from their long journey, these grieving Jewish refugees faced illness from the high altitude. They had to adapt to a foreign language and culture, and they missed the Austrian foods, art, and music to which they were accustomed.

Orly explains:

So much of being in this new place was observation. I didn’t know how anything in this world worked; I had to watch how Bolivians moved and talked and played, so I could relearn everything. My mother and father and I were like children again, not understanding how to buy food, what it should cost, how to greet a stranger, or where to find soap. Here, all my Austrian impulses were wrong. Every day I found myself in a culturally coded world without the key.

As the novel’s title suggests, music plays a major role in the story.

The absence of their former rich musical tradition symbolizes the life they left behind. Orly’s father, Jakob, had been a violist in the Vienna Philharmonic, and her mother, Julia, a renowned opera singer. Jakob finds consolation in playing his viola alone and in ensemble groups and by taking on students. Julia refuses to sing and is unable or unwilling to move on and build a new life.  

Steil skillfully organizes the novel’s chapters into musical sections: Overture/Prologue; First Movement/Vienna (Hitler’s rise, the invasion of Austria, life under the Nazis, the approaching doom, the family’s chance to escape); Second Movement/Between Worlds (the long journey to Bolivia); Third Movement/La Paz (settling in); Fourth Movement/After the War; Fifth Movement/Old Friends; and Sixth Movement/New Life.  

Some of the most moving passages in the novel deal with how Jewish members of the Vienna Philharmonic were treated by the other musicians. Looking back on that time, Orly says:

Close to half of his colleagues eventually became Nazis…There is no record of any musician in the orchestra every protesting the expulsion of his Jewish colleagues. These men who had played alongside Jews for decades…were the men now calling for their exile. For their deaths.

As the years pass, Orly comes of age in La Paz. She learns Spanish and eventually attends university. She absorbs Bolivia’s complex mixed Spanish and indigenous cultures, guided by Miquel, a neighbor Bolivian boy. She strives to integrate her two disparate lives – the new life she is creating and her lost past in Austria, including childhood Christian friend, Anneliese, with whom she experienced the beginnings of an erotic relationship.

Rounding out this well-structured novel, adult Orly, now a mother married to her childhood friend Miquel, must choose between her two lives when Anneliese, the friend she left behind in Austria, appears in La Paz and begs her to return to Europe so they can live out their childhood love.

How can you recover from devastating loss of loved ones and of everything from your past life? How can you rebuild your life in an unfamiliar culture? How can you move on from a traumatic past? These are questions Steil ponders through her vivid protagonist in this enthralling and brilliantly written novel.


Marcia R. Rudin is the author of two novels – Hear My Voice and Flower Toward the Sun – and co-author of Why Me? Why Anyone? and Prison or Paradise: The New Religious Cults.