What Does it Mean to "Code Switch" in Jewish Spaces?

March 7, 2019Chaim Ezra Harrison

Whenever I enter Jewish spaces, whether it’s my first time or my fiftieth, I make a conscious effort to bring one or all of the following: my kippah (head covering), my Sh’ma bracelet, and my Magen David (Star of David) necklace.

I wear these items because I love being Jewish, and physical reminders of my Judaism help me feel more at home while attending Shabbat services, festivals, etc. – but I also bring them because, as a black person entering majority white Jewish spaces, I feel like I have to.

When I attend Jewish events without these totems, my past experiences nag at me. All the times I’ve been given strange stares as soon as I’ve walked in. All the times I’ve been asked, “What brings you here?” which is sometimes a nicer way of saying, “What are you doing here?” All the times congregants – and even clergy – assumed I lack basic Jewish knowledge.

These experiences and more tell me that if I don’t literally wear my Judaism on my sleeve (and my head and neck), I may not be accepted. So I put on my kippah and my necklace and my bracelet and hope, deep down, that the stares and questions won’t come once I walk in – and even then, they still sometimes do.

This is my own personal version of “code switching,” the act of adjusting one’s language or behavior between conversations or environments, mainly in an attempt to cater to the language and behavior of the dominant culture.

For instance, I rarely wear a kippah in everyday life, but I always wear one when I go to Shabbat services. When I speak to other Jews, I occasionally insert Yiddish phrases as if to prove how immersed I am in (specifically European) Jewish culture. I make sure that I speak “articulately,” lest my vernacular be seen as something treif (unkosher). I make sure every statement I make about Judaism is accurate, even just in passing conversation, or else others might think I’m an idiot or, even worse – a fraud.

This is an issue white Jews almost never have to face.

If a white person walks into a Jewish space without physical displays of their Judaism, chances are, nobody will question them, their Judaism, or their identities. Nobody will find their presence odd or necessitating random questions about them walking through the door. This is because for many the default image of a Jew is a white person – which is not only incorrect, it’s problematic.

If our goal is to create more audaciously hospitable Jewish spaces, it is important to allow Jews of Color to be themselves. We should not have to feel required to flaunt our Judaism twice as much as our white Jewish family to be fully accepted and included.

The fact of the matter is that as more and more individuals continue to self-identify as Jews of Color, we’re going to see many more folks walk into our communities with dreadlocks, with different accents, with attire and vernaculars and identities and experiences that don’t fit the prescribed North American Jewish “mold.” This is not only OK, it’s beautiful – and it’s Jewish. Let us all come as we are, so we can better build and improve our wonderful Jewish communities authentically and audaciously.

Related Posts

Reflecting on Transgender Awareness Week in 2021

November 16, 2021
Transgender Awareness Week is a chance to educate the public. It is important for people who are not part of the trans community to understand the oppression transgender and gender-expansive people face every day. While it is always important to affirm trans identities, Transgender Awareness Week provides an opportunity to center the voices of trans and gender-expansive people.

A Jewish Approach to Transgender Awareness Week

November 9, 2021
After services one Friday night, I was approached by a woman and child I had not seen before. The woman knew I was a rabbinical student, and said she had an important question to ask me. Then, slowly, trying to find the right words, she said, “Let’s say there was someone who was born female but realized they were male—a female to male transgender person. Would that person be able to have a bar mitzvah? Is that something Judaism would allow?”

A Letter to My Charlottesville Congregation

October 27, 2021
I write this as the Sines vs. Kessler trial commences. This long-awaited lawsuit seeks to hold the organizers of the deadly 2017 Unite the Right rally accountable for their actions. Bone-chilling evidence will be presented in this trial that will make us realize how close we came to experiencing an even greater tragedy than the death of Heather Heyer and the wounding of so many others.